16
Sep
08

I’m not honest but you’re really interesting

I am finding more and more that people really struggle to be honest.  I don’t mean honest in the sense that it’s a fight to tell the truth any time they are asked a question, more in the sense of admitting what we feel.  It seems telling people what they don’t want to hear or what we are afraid to admit had become harder to do than explaining the plot to LOST.  On one side of the coin we have people who can’t find the nerve to tell you the truth about anything that might upset you.  Your appearance, your behavior, or anything else personal.  We think we are saving you from some kind of pain or embarrassment by not admitting we really don’t like your shirt, tattoo, or your questionable behavior.  No one wants to be the bad guy and step up and level with you.  I read an article a little while back about being brutally honest.  And while I don’t agree with the line of thinking that you should tell people how you feel about them all the time, a little more honesty in our lives doesn’t sound like that bad an idea.  Less walking on eggshells, less awkward situations, and maybe a little deeper understanding of the people around you.  I don’t mean walking up to someone and telling they you have always thought that they were an asshole but maybe come clean with someone about why you don’t really hang out with them all that often.  “I don’t mind being civil with you because we share a few friends but I find we don’t really have a lot in common so I don’t want to go out of my way to see you”.  I think this might clean up some of the social conflicts that escalate far beyond where they need to.  “He’s just not that into you”?  Well maybe he should be up front and tell you that instead of dancing around the subject and letting you keep thinking that there is something there when he has already made up his mind that there isn’t.  “I don’t think I could date you because I wouldn’t want to ruin our friendship”.  How about instead you say “I like being friends with you but I am not attracted to you so I know it wouldn’t work out”.  Cut through the maybes and the might be’s.  If you aren’t 100% decided, say that.  “I do like you but I know right now this won’t work so I’m not going to put either of us through this”.  Don’t leave things open ended.

We can all agree its better to rip the band-aid off than to slowly pull every hair out with it while we watch.  Don’t waste your time or anyone else’s time by trying not to hurt their feelings with changing the subject and half truths.  “No, I don’t think that’s a good idea.  I know you are really proud of it but that my opinion.”  The other person may take it as personal but, you know what? it is personal.  Its personal in the sense that you care enough to tell them the truth regardless of what will happen.  I don’t think you should tell a cancer patient they don’t look good if they ask but I don’t think you should tell a friend that giant piece of metal in their face is “super cute” if you don’t honestly think that.  Most of the time people are just looking for the ego boost so they shouldn’t be offended.  If they really wanted your approval they should have asked before they got it done.  They may never ask your opinion on their appearance again but they know where to go if they want someone to tell them the truth when no one else will.  I don’t know about you but I would rather someone respect me for my honesty than like me for my conformity.

On the flip side, we have the internal struggle.  Honesty with ones self is just as hard if not harder.  We have all done things we knew were a bad idea, hung out with people we knew were no good for us, made decisions based on lies we tell ourselves.  We lie to ourselves to keep a our ideals alive.  We tell ourselves we are doing something for the right reasons when we know that its nothing but a selfish act.  We do all these things to avoid taking a hard look at who we are.  We buy into what people say about us and what we wish we were and pretend that is who we are.  We lie to ourselves to keep us thinking that is the real me even when we know its not.  We go out every Saturday night even when we would rather stay home and do nothing.  We tell ourselves we want to but its only to keep up the idea that you are a fun person who’s always on the go and that is what fun people do.  We tell ourselves that we don’t care about how some people treat us to keep from thinking about how much it would hurt if we actually did.  We say we are better off without people to ignore the feelings we still have for them.  If we start admitting that we hurt, that we don’t have to live up to other’s expectation, and that it’s ok to not like things about ourselves we can start trying to work on fixing those things.  Don’t lie and tell yourself you don’t miss your ex when they are always in the back of your head.  Start thinking about what went wrong and if you still miss them, start trying to move on in a healthy way.  Don’t keep telling yourself you are a generous person when you only give for the attention.  Come to terms with it and start thinking about what it really means to be a giving person.  My guess is you already know.  Admit to yourself that you only have feelings for that person because of their physical appearance and realize you have been training yourself to “like” their personality.  Stop sacrificing personal happiness for aesthetics or a fear of letting someone down.

The sooner you can examine yourself and be be honest with you, the easier it will be to tell other people the truth about how you feel.  Help them be honest with themselves by asking “do you really care about that or do you just tell youself that to feel better about who you are?”  Have tact but don’t be afraid to step on some toes.  If they are a friend, they will respect you for it.  If they don’t, they weren’t a friend to begin with.  So feel free to leave me a comment telling me what you really think about all this.  Don’t pull any punches.  Don’t be afraid of what my reaction will be.  Don’t hold back because you don’t want to hurt my feelings.  Just make sure you are honest about what you actually feel.


11 Responses to “I’m not honest but you’re really interesting”


  1. 1 guilmette
    September 16, 2008 at 12:34 pm

    i think what you’re talking about is more about being critical than being honest… i know to be critical you have to be honest but to be honest doesn’t mean you have to be critical…. going back to that timeless saying “if you don’t have anything nice to say, don’t say it at all.” If someone has a piece of metal on their face (lol i assume you mean a piercing) and they ask what you think of it, you can give an honest answer without being critical and making a person feel bad. For example, you can say “if it makes you happy and you think it looks good than thats all that matters, you shouldn’t care what people think.” Some people might see that as a cop out but thats more honest (in my opinion) than just saying “yeah…i think it looks ugly, sorry…” I know people who are like this…and it doesn’t necessarily do any good to either person. It’s more important for people to learn that what other people think doesn’t matter, than for people to learn that you should always give your opinion on something even if its negative. however, i agree, on the other hand, you shouldn’t just say “yeah it looks good.” But these are small issues i think…theres more significant things to be honest about.

    that being said, i think being critical of someone is a very hard thing to do because you don’t want to hurt them, and that’s understandable, but true honesty, like taking the blame for something that is your fault that was pinned on someone else even though you know you will be in trouble, is more noble. Or calling in to your boss and saying you were hoping to get off work to go see a concert and you will help by working extra hours or finding a replacement, rather than just calling in sick the day of the concert. Or playing volleyball and admitting to everyone that you actually did tip the ball out of bounds even though everyone didnt think you did….even if that costs you the game.

  2. 2 digitaladd
    September 16, 2008 at 1:02 pm

    Your example is just what I am talking about. If you got a piercing and asked me what I thought about it and would rather hear “if it makes you happy and you think it looks good than thats all that matters, you shouldn’t care what people think.” than “eh, im not a fan” then you didn’t really want my opinion, you wanted someone to agree with you. Both are saying the same thing, one is just more direct. If I was picking out an outfit for a date and asked your opinion i wouldnt want you to say “if it makes you happy and you think it looks good..” I would want you to say “that shirt looks weird on you, i would change it”. Thats the difference between an opinion and fishing for a compliment. I never asked people what they thought of my tattoo’s because i don’t care if they like them or not. I ran the idea by a few people before I got them to see what their opinion was on the idea but now that I have them I don’t show them and ask “what do you think?”

    When I mentioned being tactful I meant there is no reason to offer a negative comment without being asked for it but if confronted, say what you feel. There are times when you should exercise the “if you have nothing nice to say” principal but when it comes to someone looking for an honest opinion, you are doing both of you a disservice by not being 100% truthful about it.

  3. 3 Reggie
    September 16, 2008 at 1:04 pm

    you don’t think the pieces of metal in my face are super cute?
    wow…you’re an asshole…..haha

    But seriously, Amen to this. I wish that more people kept this philosophy in mind when dealing with people they know and care about. I’d like to think that I try my best to do the same, but of course its not always the case.

    I think one of the worse things to realize is that someone you thought you were close to may have an opinion of you other than the one they show to your face. Obviously, in any group of people, things that are said about others when they are not around almost always get back to them. The source of so-called “drama”. No one seems to get that if you were up front about how you felt about someone in the first place that this problem wouldn’t exist. Like you said, just because you don’t particularly get along with someone doesn’t mean that you can’t be civil when you are around each other. Just because you’re not friendly with someone, does not mean you’re going to be an asshole to them. People too often make the mistake of trying to be friends with people that they either don’t need to be, or maybe don’t even really enjoy. It’s just not worth wasting all that time, and it only leads to problems down the line.

    I think the biggest point to realize is that being honest is not “being mean”. Its being respectful of someone else. It’s letting them really know what the deal is. It lets them know exactly where you stand. There are no points left to read too much into. It is what it is. I’ve gotten so tired lately of people complaining of girls/boys being “crazy”. No one is crazy, we all just suck at telling each other the truth. We say one thing to your face and then the next minute we’re telling someone the exact opposite. None of this would be a problem if we all learned how to be adults and not only be honest, but also to be mature enough to hear an opinion of ourselves and our behavior that might not be the most positive.

    Think I go out too much? That I don’t make the best choices in my personal life? A little upset by what I said that one time we hung out? Cool. Tell me too my face. I’ll try and hear what you have to say and hopefully take it into consideration, and even if I don’t at least I’ll know where you and I stand. There is a bumper sticker I found on facebook (of course, my newest obsession) that states: the worst part of being lied to is knowing you weren’t worth the truth. Honesty is showing someone that you respect them, that they are at least worth it enough as a person to know the truth.

    I’m glad you posted this, as I have been feeling the same recently and hadn’t been able to really clearly define it in my head. So thanks for putting it into words!

  4. 4 danielle
    September 16, 2008 at 2:29 pm

    This is why you’re my therapist.

  5. 5 guilmette
    September 16, 2008 at 2:51 pm

    well i still think the “truth” is that if you like something and think it looks good than it shouldn’t matter what people think… and the people who ask “does this look good” who are either A) are only looking for compliments or B) really are curious how it looks, still need to know that the “truth” is that it doesnt matter what I think. It matters what they think. And they shouldn’t really be asking if all they want is a compliment and they shouldn’t be asking because they are worried it might look bad to other people…

    if you want to ask me “which shirt would work best for a movie date” then i’ll tell you… “any shirt works for a movie date…its just a date, don’t try so hard…wear what YOU feel comfortable in, not whatyou think your date wants to see you in” or i’ll tell you, “i have no clue, what am i the host of ‘what not to wear?’” or “i guess the blue shirt but i really dont know dude” but what i probably wont do is say “i dont like those shirts on you” because 1) i’m not your date and 2) i’m not you

    i don’t want to get off your point of telling people how you feel because that is a good message, and i’m a big supporter of honesty. (it’s in my general interests on my myspace page…what i can’t use that as proof? i have to actually exhibit some honesty? dango…haha..) I think we need more honest people… all i was saying is that i think you’re talking more about critiquing someone and being brutally honest because “they asked for it” than honesty as a general part of a persons personality…

    dude…i’m just being honest… ha

  6. 6 digitaladd
    September 16, 2008 at 3:20 pm

    Bryman, I love you to death but your comments are sooooo frustrating.

    If I asked you for your opinion on what to wear and you said that I would stop asking you for your opinion because it shows you don’t have confidence in your opinions or you are too afraid of having someone get mad at you which is the point of this whole post. When someone approaches you for your opinion on something, give it to them straight. Don’t dodge it and tell them what they want to hear or what you think they want to hear. “If it was me, I would wear the blue shirt.” Done. If I don’t like the blue shirt, I won’t wear it. No one gets hurt. I asked, you responded, i took it into consideration, i decided i didn’t like it. End of issue. The point isn’t what I wear, it was that I asked you what you thought because I trust your opinion because I respect you. By dodging the question you make me think I should question that trust or respect because you might not trust or respect your own opinion. If I get in a car wreck and my face gets messed up, feel free to say “it will be fine in the end as long as you like who you are inside” or something hallmark-ish like that but if I trust you enough to consider your opinion, please be honest with me.

  7. 7 guilmette
    September 16, 2008 at 3:55 pm

    i dont think that means i don’t have confidence in my opinions at all, i’m all for giving opinions… i give lots of opinions and i’m confident in them.

    “if it was me, i’d wear the blue shirt”…thats definitely an honest answer…in the fact that its not a “lie” but that doesnt help YOU does it? so what if it was me…its NOT me…its YOU…

    another example…if you were thinking “i like this black shirt on me and its comfortable, but let me ask brian what he thinks” and i say “if it was ME, i’d go with the blue shirt” and you then decide “well brian would wear the blue, so i’ll wear the blue” what does that say? it says something about YOUR confidence… not mine… if i say to you “dude, it doesnt matter what i’d wear, it matters what you would wear” then you will most likely end up wearing the black shirt because thats the one YOU like… therefore I’ve done my job as a friend… and it wasnt becaue i was afraid that my opinion (liking the blue shirt for me personally) was the wrong opinion, it was because you know to wear what you want to wear, do what you want to do, pierce what you want to pierce, and hope that you have friends around that arent going to tellyou what THEY would do, but rather, make you feel confident in your own decisions.

    and if you were to ever get in a car accident and your face was messed up, the right thing to say would be that it WILL be fine in the end… you are a good person and scars aren’t going to stop you getting anything you want unless you make them stop you. Would you want me to say “dude you’re face looks pretty bad, a lot of girls will probably not date you because of your face, or people might stare at you for the rest of your life”?? sure thats the truth but is that something you didn’t already know? why do i have to tell you again… its better for me to make you feel like you can make the best out of the situation your in and move on. I would never say to you “dude, those scars make you look hot, girls will be all over you”…cause thats not the truth.

    Lnobody has to ever tell me i’m overweight or fat or chubby or anything anymore.. I don’t care how close of a friend you are… its not something i want to hear because i already know it… not because its going to hurt myfeelings, but because i already know it. tell me “wow dude you look good you’ve lost weight” and thats awesome if you really feel that way, i appreciate that and i love hearing things like that… or tell me “dude if your confident, it won’t matter that some people are shallow, you’ll meet the right people who like you for who you are”… thats the truth… but don’t tell me i look fat… cause its like, no shit? i’m not skinny.

  8. 8 guilmette
    September 16, 2008 at 3:58 pm

    and just to clarify when i say “make you feel like you can make the best out of the situation you’re in and move on”

    that is the truth… just because there are people out there who may think scars are nasty…doesn’t mean there aren’t people who don’t let things like that effect their judgment of others….

  9. 9 digitaladd
    September 16, 2008 at 4:13 pm

    Opinion: n; a view, judgment, or appraisal formed in the mind about a particular matter.

    You are going waaaaay too deep into this. When someone asks you for your opinion, they want to know what YOU think. What you are saying is advice. Blue or red is an opinion. Don’t sweat it, we love you no matter what color you pick is advice. If I ask for your opinion, it should be biased. It should be completely subjective and based on what YOU think. You are going off the deep end about empathy and being tactful when the topic at hand is giving someone your honest opinion when asked for it.

    you are going to give me an ulcer

  10. 10 guilmette
    September 16, 2008 at 4:56 pm

    blue or red is a choice…. offering “advice” as to which to choose is offering your opinion.

    here’s a definition:

    ADVICE: n.

    1. Opinion about what could or should be done about a situation or problem; counsel.

    i don’t think i’m getting too deep at all or falling off any deep end… i’m not saying that critiquing someone is dishonest…i’m saying there’s more to honesty than critiquing someone. i’m saying you don’t always have to be “brutally” honest to be considered honest..

    and i also believe everything should be looked at deeply. especially in an open discussion.

    and i don’t think i ever said i wouldn’t say “yes that lip ring looks good” or “no that nose ring looks bad”… i simply said i would probably say yes if i truly thought it, and also say that if you like it than thats all that matters… if i thought it didn’t look good, i would love to say no, because thats the right thing to say, but no matter what, the person should like what they wear or do to their body in the end….and they should also know that fishing for compliments is lame sauce. how’s that for honesty?

    ryan: when would someone with so much skill in picking out pants need to ask me and john for advice? ;) haha

  11. 11 digitaladd
    September 16, 2008 at 5:47 pm

    AND I’M SAYING YOU SHOULD BE BRUTALLY HONEST SOMETIMES BECAUSE YOU ARE LYING TO THAT PERSON IF YOU SAY ANYTHING LESS THAN WHAT YOU TRULY FEEL! I FEEL LIKE I’M TAKING CRAZY PILLS!


Leave a Reply




Blog Stats

  • 1,210 People just like you

 

September 2008
S M T W T F S
« Aug   Nov »
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
282930